New candles & jewelry!

Free Shipping On Orders $75+

Abandoned Carts are on the website!

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping
howdy

Stay in touch!

Signup and get 10% off your first purchase and receive emails for future website/livesale updates!

By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time

Forgotten Rarities

126 Results

Clear filters
$10 & Under - Grab & GO

$10 & Under - Grab & GO

from $2.50

1 oz Dried Botanicals – 40 Craft & Display Varieties

1 oz Dried Botanicals – 40 Craft & Display Varieties

from $9.99

10-Piece Tea Light Candle Set – Square & Star Packs 🔥✨

10-Piece Tea Light Candle Set – Square & Star Packs 🔥✨

$20.00

3oz Zodiac Candles

3oz Zodiac Candles

$6.00

Abandoned Carts / Live Sale Leftovers / Bundle Deals

Abandoned Carts / Live Sale Leftovers / Bundle Deals

from $30.00

Adjustable 925 Sterling Silver Gemstone Rings

Adjustable 925 Sterling Silver Gemstone Rings

from $16.00

Amethyst Cut Base

Amethyst Cut Base

from $9.00

Ammonites From Madagascar (Comes with stand)

Ammonites From Madagascar (Comes with stand)

from $36.00

Anatomically Correct 2 Inch Crystal Skulls

Anatomically Correct 2 Inch Crystal Skulls

from $24.00

arcstep587 7/11/25
Sold out

arcstep587 7/11/25

$17.98

athenaharmon 7/11/25

athenaharmon 7/11/25

$4.99

athenaharmon 7/4/25

athenaharmon 7/4/25

$1,501.35

Azurite/Malachite Clusters from Morocco

Azurite/Malachite Clusters from Morocco

from $16.00

Bail Pin Necklaces On 18" Stainless Steel Chain

Bail Pin Necklaces On 18" Stainless Steel Chain

from $12.00

bboodles15 7/11/25
Sold out

bboodles15 7/11/25

$31.00

beautyisconfidence 7/11/25
Sold out

beautyisconfidence 7/11/25

$35.00

beautyisconfidence_ashj 6/16/2025

beautyisconfidence_ashj 6/16/2025

$25.00

Live sale order

beautyisconfidenc_ashj 6/6/2025

$26.00

Blue Lace Agate Geodes

Blue Lace Agate Geodes

from $26.00

Blue Lace Agate Specimens

Blue Lace Agate Specimens

$5.00

Brandberg Clusters

Brandberg Clusters

from $41.00

Brazilian Amethyst Clusters

Brazilian Amethyst Clusters

from $6.00

Cabochon Stretchy Bangles Bracelets

Cabochon Stretchy Bangles Bracelets

$15.00

Candle Sets
Sold out

Candle Sets

$25.00

caroline.a.martin 7/11/25

caroline.a.martin 7/11/25

$12.00

Chrysocolla Druze

Chrysocolla Druze

from $27.00

creatively_redacted 6/20/2025

creatively_redacted 6/20/2025

$105.50

creatively_redacted 7/4/25

creatively_redacted 7/4/25

$23.00

Crystal Confetti 100 Gram Bags

Crystal Confetti 100 Gram Bags

from $4.99

Crystal Heart Carvings

Crystal Heart Carvings

from $8.00

Crystal Moon Carvings

Crystal Moon Carvings

from $9.00

Crystal Mushroom Carvings

Crystal Mushroom Carvings

from $9.00

Crystal Slabs

Crystal Slabs

from $20.00

Crystal Spheres

Crystal Spheres

from $8.00

Crystal Towers

Crystal Towers

from $9.00

day_dreamer_10 7/11/25
Sold out

day_dreamer_10 7/11/25

$35.00

dragonsoulsisters 7/11/25
Sold out

dragonsoulsisters 7/11/25

$84.97

drysalami 7/11/25
Sold out

drysalami 7/11/25

$12.00

earthycow 7/11/25
Sold out

earthycow 7/11/25

$233.98

elandriath 7/11/25
Sold out

elandriath 7/11/25

$8.00

Recently viewed

Adjustable 925 Sterling Silver Gemstone Rings

Adjustable 925 Sterling Silver Gemstone Rings

from $16.00

Stud Earrings

Stud Earrings

from $10.00

Stretchy Crystal Tumble Bracelets

Stretchy Crystal Tumble Bracelets

$8.00

Bail Pin Necklaces On 18" Stainless Steel Chain

Bail Pin Necklaces On 18" Stainless Steel Chain

from $12.00

Stainless Steel Rings

Stainless Steel Rings

$8.00

2 colors, 5 sizes
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
Cabochon Stretchy Bangles Bracelets

Cabochon Stretchy Bangles Bracelets

$15.00

Fluorite Butterfly Stud Earrings

Fluorite Butterfly Stud Earrings

$20.00

4 colors
Fully Beaded Necklaces

Fully Beaded Necklaces

$50.00

Handmade Jewelry

View all
Intention Soy Candles in 12 oz & 6 oz

Intention Soy Candles in 12 oz & 6 oz

from $12.50

2 sizes
  • 12 OZ
  • 6 OZ
3oz Zodiac Candles

3oz Zodiac Candles

$6.00

Magick Melts

Magick Melts

$6.00

10-Piece Tea Light Candle Set – Square & Star Packs 🔥✨

10-Piece Tea Light Candle Set – Square & Star Packs 🔥✨

$20.00

Candle Sets
Sold out

Candle Sets

$25.00

I discovered FR when they followed me on Instagram and I am SO glad I decided to check them out!!!! The best people, best prices, and best live sale community 🤍 I have really expanded my collection over the last year and 98% of it is thanks to Forgotten Rarities! They have a gorgeous variety on their website as well! All around the best crystal crew I've found 🥰

– @hottsarahh

The best crystal warehouse, showroom, live sales, quality pieces, fun people and friends ever!

– @coastalminded